CollectionCount
by CardCollective

1951 Topps Connie Mack All-Stars Baseball Checklist

Connie Mack's own all-time team — 11 oversized die-cut stand-up cards of all-time greats, issued in 1951. The cards are unnumbered and are listed here in the catalogs' standard alphabetical order. Check off the cards you have, print a want list, or export your progress.

11 cards in the base set
Join YouTube Breaks Join the Facebook group
Key stars

Every man on Connie Mack's all-time team is a Hall of Famer — there are no rookie cards in this set. Tap a star to jump to his card.

In 1951, in its very first year making baseball cards, Topps issued this tribute to the game's past: eleven oversized cards of the all-time team picked by Connie Mack, the Philadelphia Athletics manager who had just finished fifty seasons running the club. The set is billed on the cards themselves as "Connie Mack's All-Time All-Star Team," and every man on it — the ten players and Mack himself — is in the Hall of Fame.

The cards are unlike anything else Topps ever made. Each one is tall — 2-1/16" × 5-1/4" — with a black-and-white action photo printed on a red background above a name plate carrying the player's name, nickname, team, position, years in the league and a facsimile signature. The figure is die-cut: the back carries a short biography and folding instructions, and the card folds so the player stands up on his own. That design is also why these cards so rarely survive whole — kids punched out and folded the stand-ups, and the backgrounds were often torn away or lost entirely, so complete examples are genuinely scarce.

Mack's team lines up like a real ballclub: Grover Alexander, Walter Johnson and Christy Mathewson on the mound, Mickey Cochrane catching, Lou Gehrig at first, Eddie Collins at second, Honus Wagner at short, Jimmy Collins at third, and Babe Ruth and Tris Speaker in the outfield, with Mack himself as the manager. The cards were never numbered, so the catalogs list them alphabetically by last name — the order used on this page. There are no parallels, inserts, autographs or relics in this set: the eleven die-cuts are the whole thing.

Checklist © Topps. Set information compiled from the standard published hobby catalogs and set references.

There were no hobby boxes in 1951 — that way of selling cards came decades later. The Connie Mack All-Stars were never sold on their own at all: each one reached a kid as the premium card inside a pack of Topps' regular 1951 cards. The five-cent "Baseball Candy" packs held four perforated two-card panels of Red Backs or Blue Backs plus one bonus oversized card — either a Connie Mack All-Star or a Topps Teams card — with a piece of caramel kept away from the cards by its own wrapper inside the pack.

The All-Stars also came in Topps' bundle packs, sold with a full set of Red Backs and Topps Teams cards alongside them. Either way, there was no box to buy and no case to split: collecting all eleven meant pulling them one pack at a time, or trading for the ones that never turned up.

Tap a team to filter

The checklist

Track your collection

Base set: 0 of 11 collected

Pick a team above to see your team progress.

Expand which view below you want to track.

There is no parallel of this set, so no card below carries a parallel expansion.

Tap View menu above to jump to a specific view you're wanting to track.

Tap Got it on any card — checks save on your account when you're signed in.

Saved sets live under My Checklists.

Collect with the group

Thousands of collectors trade flagship baseball cards in our Facebook group, and breaks run live on YouTube. Come say hello.

Join the Facebook group · Join YouTube Breaks